Chief endures for now
So I got my knickers in a twist last week, and then the
vote was postponed. So the Chief will likely live to dance another fall at least...
As some of you perhaps have seen in the Comments section below, The Squire had quite a bit to say about the Chief. He's a student, and he is entitled to his opinion -- offering them in a couple differents comments on the post below. However, I'm an Illinois taxpayer that supports this institution...so I think I'm also entitled to my two cents on the matter.
I beg to differ with the idea that the Chief is a racist symbol...on several different accounts. Account one: my husband and my Illini-alum brother-in-law are descendants of the Fox tribe. Not enough that you would know it if you passed them on the street but enough that they can check Native American on the census. They are also the two biggest Chief supporters I know. The fact that they are going to lose this mascot is burning them up. When this vote is held in July, I have been warned that they will be protesting on the quad, holding up signs that read "Fox Nation for Illiniwek".
Account two: While growing up in this area, I had a friend or two who took place in Native American dance competitions. Details may have been different between their competitions and the Three-In-One, but the overall effect was the same: honor shown for the traditions of the group and respect exhibited for their dancing.
Perhaps the best commentary I have read on the subject comes from Liam over at
Hey Listen.
Liam offers up a rather rambling post here, but it has several humorous digressions and I say read the whole thing. It offers up two valuable links as to the history of the chief: that from
Honor the Chief and that from
Retire the Chief. He also offers up a reason by which he might support the Chief's retirement:
"My barber the other day mentioned it to me, asking what I thought of the Chief. I said what I said here, I think the halftime show is cool, but if he's gone I'll survive." She(!) said that maybe it's just important to "the townies," a generally derogatory term that I assume she was applying on purpose. It made me want to support her cause, and so I would if it went to a vote of the student body. Wouldn't it just piss off the anti-Chief crowd if the issue were settled democratically, with the student body, drunk football fans and all, voting on the issue, instead of the "Right People," the Rod appointed trustees making the decision for all us hayseeds."
To this point, I must agree with Liam and dispute the Squire's comment that HotRod is staying out of this one. He's not out of it. He appointed four trustees to the board in the months since he took office. Illiniwek was supported by 10 of 12 trustees in March 2001. The fact that Frances Carroll thought she had the votes to pass this measure indicates that either votes changed or every one of Rod's four appointees would be voting for this measure. In that respect, I must argue that he is not representing the views of his constituents well with his choices for the board, as I (editorially) believe a majority of the Illinois populace supports the mascot. As the
Herald & Review argues in an editorial today, if the trustees are going to be appointed by the governor, "it's the governor we should blame if we disagree with the board's decisions."
The Illinois Leader offers up a
perhaps-unbalanced but informative article on the issue. In this article U of I alum and State Rep. Chapin Rose is quoted as saying, "When you're that little, you don't know who is winning the ballgames, you go to see the Chief".
I'd like to take Chapin's comment a bit further. When Illinois football is terrible (like this year), you don't go to watch who is winning , you go to see the Chief. Here's to hoping I have a reason to go to the games next year, one way or the other.
FYI: I also thought I should probably clear this up -- mentioned it before but it's been a while. Despite my blog's name, I am not and have never been a student at the University of Illinois. I was born, was raised, and still reside in the figurative shadow of the university. Therefore, I grew up attending Illini games and still bleed orange and blue. (Might as well since I attended a liberal arts college instead of a Big Ten institution). While I love most of what Chambana has to offer, I sense that the nonsense quotient might have driven me crazy.
Also for the record, I didn't work for Pat O'Malley's campaign for governor. I think that was Aakash and Former Miss America Erika Harold. I appreciate being confused with her though :)